Alpha Phi Delta Fraternity
  • Home
  • About
    • National Convention 2023
    • The Fraternity >
      • Our Governance
      • Districts of the Fraternity
      • Our Past National Presidents
    • Founding Years >
      • The Beginning
      • Founders Video
      • Founder's Day
    • Headquarters and Staffing >
      • Central Office
      • Committee System
      • National Officers and District Governors
      • Our National President
    • National Award Applications >
      • Outstanding Chapter Award Application
      • Most Improved Chapter Award Application
      • Outstanding Alumni Club Application
      • Outstanding Alumni Association Application
      • Outstanding District Award Application
      • Outstanding Community Service Award Application
      • Outstanding Undergraduate Award Application
      • Outstanding Alumnus Award Application
    • Resources >
      • Our Fee Schedule
      • Our Forms >
        • Form C - Brothers Graduating or Leaving School Form
        • Form C1 - Restore Brothers to Undergraduate Status Form
        • Payments
        • Form CE - Chapter Self Evaluation Form 2017
        • Form D - Report of a Brother in Financial Arrears
        • Form D1 - Officer Reimbursement Form
        • Form DP - Report of Discipline and Probation Form
        • Form F - Faciamus Pin Award
        • Form G - Community Service, Philanthropy and Charitable Work Report Form
        • Form GPA - Academic Report Questionnaire
        • Faciamus Pin
        • Form I - Undergraduate Chapters and Colonies Change of Officers Form
        • Form IFP - Initiation Fee Payment
        • Form IR - Undergraduate Chapters & Colonies Change of Officers Form Revisions
        • Form I-2 - Alumni Club and Association Change of Officers Form
        • Form I-3 - District / District Convention Change of Officers Form
        • Form K - Kleos Submission Form
        • Form L - Prospective Member Questionnaire Form
        • Form LC - Correction of Membership Card/Certificate Form
        • Form LX - Membership Card/Certificate Order Form
        • Form NC - National Council Delegate Registration Form
        • Form W - APD Website News Reporting Form
      • Our Education and Risk Management Resources
      • Our Publications >
        • Constitution and Bylaws
        • Ecce Signum
        • Kleos
        • The Kleos
        • Annual Reports
        • Chapter Leadership Guide
    • News >
      • APD on Facebook
      • Fraternity News
      • Interfraternal News
      • Italian Cultural News
      • Our Calendar
    • Miscellaneous >
      • 12 Days of Alpha Phi Delta Christmas
      • Activities Page
      • Undergraduate Membership Status Chart
      • Our Heraldry
      • Our Songs
      • Frank Sinatra's Birthday
      • Christmas
      • Feedback
  • Undergrads
    • Our Chapters
    • Chapters in Action
    • Starting a Chapter of Alpha Phi Delta
  • Alumni
    • Our Alumni Clubs >
      • Brooklyn Alumni Club Page
      • Chicago Alumni Club Page
      • Connecticut Alumni Club Page
      • Colorado Alumni Club Page
      • Delaware Valley Alumni Club Page
      • Long Island Alumni Club Page
      • Lower Hudson Valley Alumni Club Page
      • Merrimack Alumni Alumni Club Page
      • Naples Alumni Club Page
      • New York Alumni Club Page
      • North Jersey Alumni Club Page
      • Pittsburgh Alumni Club Page
      • South Florida Alumni Club Page
      • Steubenville Alumni Club Page
      • Youngstown Alumni Club Page
    • Our Alumni Associations >
      • Beta Eta Alumni Association Page
      • Beta Lambda Alumni Association Page
      • Beta Sigma Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Iota Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Mu Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Omicron Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Pi Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Rho Alumni Association Page
      • Gamma Sigma Alumni Association Page
      • Delta Epsilon Alumni Association Page
      • Delta Theta Alumni Association Page
      • Delta Xi Alumni Association Page
      • Delta Rho Alumni Association Page
      • Epsilon Gamma Alumni Association Page
    • Update Contact Info
    • Starting an Alumni Club or Association
    • Alumni Network
  • Foundation
    • Memorial2
    • Donate-Now
    • Foundation Home
    • APD Cares
    • Cultural Heritage
    • Chapter Histories >
      • Alpha
      • Beta
      • Gamma
      • Delta
      • Epsilon
      • Zeta
      • Eta
      • Theta
      • Iota
      • Lambda
      • Mu
      • Nu
      • Xi
      • Omicron
      • Pi
      • Rho
      • Phi
      • Chi
      • Psi
      • Tau
      • Theta Beta
      • Beta Beta
      • Beta Delta
      • Beta Zeta
      • Beta Iota
      • Beta Lambda
      • Beta Xi
      • Beta Rho
      • Gamma Zeta
      • Gamma Lambda
      • Chapter Template
    • Cultural History
    • Leadership Fund
    • Philanthropy
    • Publications
    • Scholarship
  • Shop
    • *NEW* History of Alpha Phi Delta 1914-2020
    • APD 2019-20 Yearbook
    • APD Bookstore for Fraternity Books
    • APD Jeweler - Herff Jones
    • Central Office Store
    • Shop APD
    • Spirit Recognition
    • Christmas Catalogue 2016
    • Graduation Stole
  • Contact
    • Contact

Greek Councils, Administrators Clash on Fraternity Discipline

6/23/2015

0 Comments

 
PictureEmbattled Greeks: Fraternities battle against school administrators the matter of discipline vs. self-discipline.
(June 23, 2015) In May, Pennsylvania State University banned its chapter of Kappa Delta Rho -- the fraternity that maintained a private Facebook page that featured photographs of nude and partially nude unconscious women -- from campus for three years. The decision, which was made after an investigation into the Facebook page also revealed incidents of sexual harassment and hazing within the chapter, overturned an earlier ruling by the university’s Interfraternity Council. The council had recommended that the chapter keep its recognition but undergo education and training about sexual assault and bystander intervention.

It was a rare move for the university, which typically defers to the all-male council to determine disciplinary action for Penn State fraternities. That means a panel of fraternity members potentially decides on the guilt or innocence and punishment of a fraternity -- in this case one accused not only of degrading women generally but of violating the privacy of and harassing specific women. “The university’s educational purposes and its responsibilities compel a stronger response than you have recommended,” Damon Sims, the university’s vice president for student affairs, wrote in a letter to the IFC. “Our commitment to student involvement in institutional decision making remains important to us, and our action in this case should not be seen as a retreat from the commitment.”

At most colleges, the punishment of wayward fraternity chapters is not often left to campus administrators, but to a panel of the fraternity members’ peers. Administrators reserve the power to reverse those decisions or ban a chapter, but that process isn't always a simple one. And, as seen at Penn State, an IFC's idea of how to appropriately punish a chapter can vastly differ from that of the university. In cases that involve sexual harassment against women, student affairs professionals and women's advocates question whether all-male panels comprised of fellow fraternity members should be the ones making those decisions. “No matter what path schools have for dealing with different student organizations, they have a responsibility to deal with this type of harassment,” said Anne Hedgepeth, government relations manager at the American Association of University Women. “Colleges are on the hook for ending hostile environments, and hearing from diverse voices in those matters is important.”

Fraternities at Penn State are private associations that are located on private property. They are governed by an interfraternity council that is associated with but independent from the university. Many colleges use a similar system: fraternities are sanctioned by the judicial boards of interfraternity councils, which fall under the umbrella of a trade association called the North-American Interfraternity Conference. Less commonly, the chapters may have their cases decided by Greek standards boards, which are similarly comprised of fraternity members but may also include sorority members. Most disciplinary decisions are made by these councils and their judicial boards. Institutions do have the power to ban a chapter from campus by de-recognizing it as a student organization. Penn State has reversed its IFC’s recommendations in the past and banned chapters from campus, Sims said, making the university’s decision last month uncommon but not unheard of. "We reserve the right to intervene whenever a governing council reaches a conclusion with which we do not agree, which was the case with the recent Kappa Delta Rho matter," Sims said this week. "Since the administration typically, though not always, has agreed with the judgment of the respective governing councils, there rarely has been reason to overturn the initial judgment of the student governing group. But we always retain the right to do so."

The case had garnered national attention, and the university promised a full investigation into the Facebook page when it came to light in March. The page, originally called “Covert Business Transactions,” had 144 active members, including both current students and alumni of the fraternity. Only one of them reported the page to Penn State and the police. The university's investigation found that in addition to posting the photographs of unconscious women in “compromising positions,” the chapter had persistently harassed two female students. In addition, members sold and used illegal drugs, the university said. The investigation revealed several instances of hazing, including forcing pledges to box one another. Pledges were also forced to hold the plank position -- an exercise where a person’s body weight is supported by their forearms -- with bottle caps digging into their elbows. “The sum of organizational misbehaviors is far more than the university can tolerate from a student organization that seeks its imprimatur,” Sims said in his letter overruling the IFC's recommendation.

Laura Dunn, executive director of SurvJustice, praised Penn State for overturning the IFC ruling and banning the fraternity, but said the fact that all-male panels are given the opportunity to make disciplinary decisions about cases that include female victims is inherently unfair. “I think the whole concept is absolutely wrong and is quickly becoming outdated,” Dunn said. “Councils can be part of this process, but any school that allows fraternities to discipline themselves in these situations is not really fulfilling their obligations to female students.” Allowing that sort of self-governance, Dunn said, could even mean colleges are not in compliance with the gender discrimination law Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which requires universities to quickly investigate and adjudicate cases of sexual harassment and gender violence. Sims said that an upcoming task force at Penn State will evaluate "whether the current arrangement should be sustained, or whether [the university] should instead segregate the management of sexual misconduct cases from other disciplinary issues managed by" Greek organizations.

Pete Smithhisler, president of the North-American Interfraternity Conference, said “peer-to-peer student accountability” is an important part of fraternity life, but that interfraternity councils and college administrators should work together when deciding how best to sanction a chapter. “Self-governance is a very good life lesson,” Smithhisler said. “We often have to learn to hold our peers accountable, and so these are skills the members learn that can be used outside of the fraternity later in life. Our thoughts related to IFCs are that they need to be promoting the fraternity experience in their own environments, holding members accountable to internal codes and working with institutions to honor student conduct codes. Working hand in hand with the college is ideal.”

At Penn State, the IFC and the national office of Kappa Delta Rho said it respected the decision made by the student affairs office to supersede the IFC’s ruling. Even so, the difference between the university's decision and the council's initial ruling is striking -- and attempts to reconcile similar differences of opinion haven't gone so well on other campuses. In March, tensions over fraternity self-governance at the University of Idaho led the Dean of Students there to resign. He announced his resignation after sanctions against the Idaho chapter of Phi Gamma Delta over hazing allegations were dropped. A month earlier, the dean's office had found the fraternity to be in violation of the university’s hazing polices. The fraternity quickly agreed to accept the sanctions proposed by the office. As part of the agreement, freshman members were no longer allowed to live in the house and the chapter was put on probation for three years. At the University of Idaho, Greek organizations accused of violating university rules have the choice of having their case heard by a Greek Community Standards Board, which includes both fraternity and sorority members, or simply having the dean of students decide the sanctions. Phi Gamma Delta originally agreed to the latter, but -- after hearing from alumni and a lawyer -- the fraternity changed its mind and asked instead for the case to be heard by the standards board.

The university allowed the chapter’s request, sending the case to the board and reversing the dean’s sanctions. “I no longer believe this is an environment where I can work on issues of student safety,” Craig Chatriand, the dean of students, said at the time. “The safety of our students is the primary concern of the dean of students’ office, and not being able to address concerns through our already established policies and agreements takes away the effectiveness of what this office can do.” The university would not say what activities the hazing had allegedly included, but the local police department also launched its own investigation into the chapter over allegations of sleep deprivation. No charges were filed. One university official, who asked to remain anonymous, said allegations as serious as hazing should not be handled by the board, but that there is no rule against it. Three months after Chatriand resigned, new sanctions have yet to be announced and the chapter remains unpunished. Stefany Bales, a spokeswoman for the University of Idaho, said the board's recommendations will not be announced until at least August.

Kevin Kruger, president of NASPA: Student Affairs Administrators in Higher Education, said while self-governance is a long-held aspect of fraternity life, college administrators should have final say in how a chapter is punished. In many cases, however, institutional policies and agreements with fraternities mean that pulling a fraternity’s recognition as a student organization, as Penn State did, is one of the few organizational punishments at an institution’s disposal. When colleges wish to ban alcohol from fraternity gatherings or to suspend such parties completely (something they've donewith some regularity in the last year), they usually turn to interfraternity councils to make those decisions, as well. “An institution doesn't have a whole lot of tools available for taking action against student organizations, outside of probation or suspension,” Kruger said. “An IFC can do more intermediate efforts to hold the fraternity accountable, allowing them to police themselves in cases such as alcohol violations. For more major cases like sexual harassment or hazing, I don't think the institution would want to allow that sort of self-policing.” (excerpted for educational purposes from the Inside Higher Ed website; byline: Jake New)

0 Comments

Students Expelled and Fraternity Closed as Univ. of Oklahoma President  Takes Action Over Inappropriate  SAE Video

3/10/2015

0 Comments

 
PictureThe now-vacant SAE at Univ. of Oklahoma
NORMAN, Okla. —University of Oklahoma President David Boren has expelled two students identified as leaders in a racist chant video recorded at an SAE fraternity event. Boren said the students who played a leadership role had created a hostile learning environment for others. The president of Jesuit Dallas High School released a statement about a graduate's involvement in the video. The statement was released shortly after Boren announced he expelled two students. Several sources have confirmed that Parker Rice was the student in the first video that surfaced on Sunday. Boren addressed a crowd of protestors on Monday, saying the sentiments in the video would not be tolerated at the University of Oklahoma. Boren also said the members of the fraternity have until midnight to get off campus.

Sunday night, the national SAE organization closed the chapter, effective immediately. National SAE president Brad Cohen said he hopes the university expels the students involved. "In addition, all of the members have been suspended (from the organization), and those members who are responsible for the incident may have their membership privileges revoked permanently," the national organization said in a statement. "We apologize for the unacceptable and racist behavior of the individuals in the video, and we are disgusted that any member would act in such a way. Furthermore, we are embarrassed by this video and offer our empathy not only to anyone outside the organization who is offended but also to our brothers who come from a wide range of backgrounds, cultures and ethnicities."

OU President David Boren released a statement Monday morning: To those who have misused their free speech in such a reprehensible way, I have a message for you. You are disgraceful. You have violated all that we stand for. You should not have the privilege of calling yourselves "Sooners." Real Sooners are not racist. Real Sooners are not bigots. Real Sooners believe in equal opportunity. Real Sooners treat all people with respect. Real Sooners love each other and take care of each other like family members. Effective immediately, all ties and affiliations between this University and the local SAE chapter are hereby severed. I direct that the house be closed and that members will remove their personal belongings from the house by midnight tomorrow. Those needing to make special arrangements for positions shall contact the Dean of Students. All of us will redouble our efforts to create the strongest sense of family and community. We vow that we will be an example to the entire country of how to deal with this issue. There must be zero tolerance for racism everywhere in our nation.

The video was posted to YouTube on Sunday reportedly showing the Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity chanting on Saturday.

The national president of SAE, Brad Cohen, said an emergency board meeting was called Sunday night to address the issue. "I was not only shocked and disappointed but disgusted by the outright display of racism displayed in the video,” said Brad Cohen, the fraternity’s national president. “SAE is a diverse organization, and we have zero tolerance for racism or any bad behavior. When we learned about this incident, I called an immediate board meeting, and we determined with no mental reservation whatsoever that this chapter needed to be closed immediately. I am proud of my fellow board members because we mean what we say.” The organization said it hopes to restart an OU chapter of SAE in the future with new members who "exemplify our beliefs and who serve as leaders on campus and in the community."

Several members of the organization moved out of the house overnight with campus police protection. The house was vandalized overnight. Someone wrote on an outside wall "Tear it down.” (excerpted from the Daily Oklahoman for education purposes; byline: Mecca Rayne)

0 Comments

    About this Page

    This page contains items from the Inter-fraternal world and the collegiate realm. Items here might deal with success stories, legal issue, behavioral problems, etc. All items on this page are excerpted for educational purposes.

    Archives

    October 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    Categories

    All
    Alcohol
    Anti Fraternity Bias
    Anti-Fraternity Bias
    Community Service
    Congress
    Discipline
    Due Process
    False Accusation
    Gamma Phi Beta
    Hazing
    Iota Phi Theta
    Kean University
    Legal
    Media
    Nu Alpha Phi
    Pennsylvania State University
    Phi Kappa Psi
    Phi Kappa Theta
    Philanthrophy
    Racism
    Rolling Stone
    Rutgers University
    Saginaw Valley State University
    San Diego State University
    Sexual Assault
    Sigma Alpha Epsilon
    Syracuse University
    Title IX
    University Of Oklahoma
    University Of Virginia
    University Of Wisconsin

    RSS Feed

Site Navigation
Home
About Us
Undergrads
Alumni
Foundation
Shop
Contact

Picture
Picture
Picture

Contact Alpha Phi Delta
By mail: 
Alpha Phi Delta Fraternity
Central Office
257 E Camden Wyoming Avenue, Unit A
Camden, DE 19934
​
Or, use our online contact form by clicking here